The results...
So, I started out with 4 wheel halfs like this...
I blasted them with some pretty arressive coal slag (Black Diamond) media, & got this...
The media worked really well, actually smoothed out some scratches, nicks, etc., but left a coarse, dry, sandblasted concrete look.
So, 20 hours or so in the tumbler & ...(in all the pics, the darker wheel with the bearing is the after pic)
My crappy cell camera doesn't show it, but the tumbled wheel has some sheen to it now. A clear coat & they'll look nice.
I'm pretty happy with how it came out.